Abandoned infants can be brought to ED
Abandoned infants can be brought to ED
Texas passes law — other states might follow
Are you prepared to handle a newborn infant abandoned in your ED? A controversial law recently passed in Texas that allows mothers to drop off infants 30 days old or younger anonymously to an emergency medical services provider. Similar legislation has been introduced in several states, including Delaware, Alabama, California, Minnesota, and Georgia.
ED providers line up on both sides about whether such laws are a good idea. But whatever your opinion, you and your staff need to be informed, notes Arlo Weltge, MD, MPH, FACEP, associate professor of emergency medicine at University of Texas Houston Medical School. "Surprisingly, there is a lack of awareness of the law on the part of EDs and EMS agencies," he says.
ACEP is developing a policy to educate the emergency medicine community about its role in this area and to encourage providers to be adequately prepared to take on that role, reports Susan Nedza, MD, FACEP, chair of the state legislative and regulatory committee for the Dallas-based American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) and an ED physician at Elmhurst (IL) Memorial Hospital. "The ACEP board will also develop a recommendation for its state chapters as to involvement in legislative efforts," she says.
In Houston, 13 abandoned children were found last year, notes Weltge. "No one wants to see abandoned children left in unsafe places, such as dumpsters. But the law, with good intentions, has potentially created problems for the child and emergency services."
It’s important to note the pros and cons of the Texas law, so you can use the information to provide input on legislation in your state, Weltge advises. Here are some issues to consider:
o No information is available about the child. The law removes all responsibility from the mother to provide any information about the abandoned child, notes Weltge. "There is no requirement that the mother leave either a note of intention that this child is being given up or a note that the child is well and has no medical problems," he says.
If you have no information about an abandoned child, your primary obligation is to look for life-threatening injuries or illnesses, says Weltge. "A newborn infant or neonate less than a month old can have many life-threatening yet relatively unapparent problems," he says. "So a healthy child potentially may be subjected to a number of unnecessary tests."
For example, infants may have a septic evaluation to determine any life-threatening problems such as infections, Weltge says. "This includes blood cultures, X-rays, and a spinal tap, because infections can easily be overwhelming at this age. An infant could get these tests unnecessarily if there is any suspicion that the child could be sick."
A child born to a mother who was addicted to drugs or alcohol will appear to be ill and would warrant extensive tests if there is no background history available, he says.
o Children might be left in other hospital locations. Although the Texas law states that the child needs to be left at a licensed emergency medical service provider to prevent prosecution of the mother, it apparently gives the mother permission to leave the child anywhere "relatively" safe, which might include the hospital bathroom or doorway, says Weltge.
o Time and resources will be spent. Because the law doesn’t require that the mother provide any information about the child, a major investment of time and resources will be needed, he notes. "ED staff will spend time on potentially unnecessary tests and utilize expensive and unnecessary resources on the child in the ED until illness can be excluded and abandonment established."
That type of scenario also tends to lead to an outpouring of emotion among ED staff, he says. "There is a lot of emotional impact invested which potentially jeopardizes the care of other patients."
o ED staff still will have to make an effort to obtain consent. The burden is on the ED to verify that no parent is available to give consent and the intention was to abandon the child, says Weltge. Even though there is implied consent when a child is abandoned, an infant who was left at an apartment complex in Houston spent several days at Texas Children’s Hospital while the issue of consent was being investigated, he notes.
You can streamline the process by making every effort to contact the next of kin or someone else who can give consent if you have any leads, says Weltge. "There is the assumption there is nobody to contact, but the appropriate agencies need to verify the fact that this is an abandoned child," he says.
o Develop a policy. Once a law is passed, a policy will need to address the clinical care of the child, involvement of social services, and the ability to meet the needs of the mother if requested, says Nedza. (See story at right.) "An agreement between the hospital’s public relations department and the law enforcement community will also help to minimize the possibility for misunderstandings and misinformation."
• Susan Nedza, MD, FACEP, Elmhurst Memorial Hospital, Emergency Department, 200 Berteau, Elmhurst, IL 60126. Telephone: (630) 833-1400, ext. 41186. Fax: (630) 941-4505. E- mail: [email protected].
• Arlo Weltge, MD, MPH, FACEP, Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Texas Houston Medical School, 6431 Fannin MSB 6.260, Houston, TX 77030. Telephone: (713) 667-4113. Fax: (713) 665-0241. E-mail: [email protected].
Subscribe Now for Access
You have reached your article limit for the month. We hope you found our articles both enjoyable and insightful. For information on new subscriptions, product trials, alternative billing arrangements or group and site discounts please call 800-688-2421. We look forward to having you as a long-term member of the Relias Media community.